# The Age of Revolutions I: the Atlantic and France

History II · Contemporary History · https://tryals.app/learn/history-ii/the-age-of-revolutions-i-the-atlantic-and-france

## One Ocean, Four Revolutions

Between 1776 and 1826, four major upheavals transformed the Atlantic world:

* The **American** Revolution (1776–1783)
* The **French** Revolution (from 1789)
* The **Haitian** Revolution (**1791**–1804)
* The **Spanish American** wars of independence (1808–1826)

Historians debate whether to view these as one connected Atlantic phenomenon.

### The French Revolution

France faced state **bankruptcy** from war debts. The Crown was forced to summon the **Estates General** in May 1789 for the first time since 1614.

| Date | Event | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| 20 June 1789 | Tennis Court Oath | Third Estate claims sovereignty |
| 14 July 1789 | Bastille falls | Popular force enters politics |
| 4 August 1789 | Night of 4 August | Feudal privileges abolished |
| 26 August 1789 | Declaration of the Rights of Man | Universal Rights asserted |
| 10 August 1792 | Tuileries stormed | Monarchy effectively ends |
| 21 January 1793 | Louis XVI executed | Republic cuts off retreat |
| 27 July 1794 | Thermidor | The Terror ends |

In November 1799, the coup of **Brumaire** brought Napoleon Bonaparte to power. He later issued the **Civil Code of 1804**, spreading legal equality across Europe.

### Haiti

**Haiti** challenged the entire colonial order. Saint-Domingue was a brutally exploited plantation colony worked by half a million enslaved people.

* In August **1791**, enslaved workers launched an uprising.
* The French Convention abolished slavery in February **1794**.
* Bonaparte tried to restore slavery in 1802 but failed.
* On **1 January 1804**, Haiti declared its independence.

Historian **Michel-Rolph Trouillot** showed that European thinkers long treated this victory as unthinkable.

### Historiography

Debates over the French Revolution remain sharp:

* The **social interpretation** viewed it as a bourgeois victory over feudalism.
* **Alfred Cobban** rejected these class definitions using empirical data on revolutionary leaders.
* **François Furet** analysed the Revolution as an ideological and political dynamic.

> **Common pitfall:** Viewing the Terror as alien to the Revolution. It arose directly from wartime pressures and revolutionary institutions.

## Practice questions

11 of this lesson's 15 practice questions, with answers. The full set is in the app.

### 1. Arrange these events of the French Revolution in order.

**Answer:**

1. The Estates General meets for the first time since 1614
2. The third estate swears the Tennis Court Oath
3. The Bastille falls to a Parisian crowd
4. The night of 4 August abolishes seigneurial privilege
5. The Declaration of the Rights of Man is adopted
6. The Tuileries is stormed and the monarchy ends in practice
7. Louis XVI is executed

**Why:** The compression of 1789 is the striking thing: a fiscal meeting in May has become a national assembly by June, a popular insurrection by July, and the abolition of an entire legal order by August. Everything from 1792 onward happens at a slower pace against far greater resistance.

Page: https://tryals.app/practice/history-ii/the-age-of-revolutions-i-the-atlantic-and-france/arrange-these-events-of-the-french-revolution-in-order

### 2. The French monarchy summoned the Estates General in 1789 for the first time since 1614. Why did it do so, and what does the reason reveal?

A. It needed national approval to finance a naval war with Britain, showing reliance on popular patriotism
B. It intended to enact an enlightened constitution like America's to modernise royal administrative bodies
C. Unable to service debt or tax privileged orders, it had to seek the consent it avoided for a century
D. Customary law required it to reassemble the three orders every century to ratify royal succession edicts

**Answer:** C. Unable to service debt or tax privileged orders, it had to seek the consent it avoided for a century

**Why:** The crisis is a fiscal one that cannot be solved without touching privilege, and privilege is what the monarchy rested on. That is why the meeting was so dangerous: convoking the estates concedes in advance that the crown cannot act alone, and once conceded the point could not be withdrawn.

Page: https://tryals.app/practice/history-ii/the-age-of-revolutions-i-the-atlantic-and-france/the-french-monarchy-summoned-the-estates-general-in-1789-for-the

### 3. Haiti is the only state in history created by a successful revolt of enslaved people.

**Answer:** True

**Why:** **True.** Other risings were crushed or produced fugitive communities on the margins of colonies. Saint-Domingue is unique: an enslaved population defeated its owners, then the French expedition sent to re-enslave it, and declared an independent state on 1 January 1804.

Page: https://tryals.app/practice/history-ii/the-age-of-revolutions-i-the-atlantic-and-france/haiti-is-the-only-state-in-history-created-by-a-successful-revolt-of

### 4. Which claims about the Terror are defensible?

A. It marks the point at which the Revolution was captured by the old regime
B. It was carried out by the same revolutionary assembly, not by an outside force
C. It used emergency powers the Revolution had itself created
D. It took place under conditions of foreign invasion, civil war and food shortage

**Answer:** B. It was carried out by the same revolutionary assembly, not by an outside force; C. It used emergency powers the Revolution had itself created; D. It took place under conditions of foreign invasion, civil war and food shortage

**Why:** The uncomfortable fact is the continuity. The same body, the same personnel and the same legal instruments produced both the Declaration and the law of 22 Prairial. Whether that makes the Terror a betrayal of the Revolution or an outcome available within it is a real argument, and it cannot be closed by attributing it to someone else.

Page: https://tryals.app/practice/history-ii/the-age-of-revolutions-i-the-atlantic-and-france/which-claims-about-the-terror-are-defensible

### 5. Complete the account of the Haitian revolution.

**Answer:** A rising began in the French colony of Saint-Domingue in **1791**, and slavery there was abolished by the Convention in February **1794**. Bonaparte sent an expedition to restore it in 1802 and it was defeated; on 1 January **1804** the colony declared independence as **Haiti**.

**Why:** The thirteen-year span is worth holding, because it includes an abolition, a re-imposition attempt, and a defeat of a European expeditionary force. That last item is why the revolution was so hard for contemporaries to narrate: it was not a moral failure of the colonial system but a military defeat inflicted by the people it enslaved.

Page: https://tryals.app/practice/history-ii/the-age-of-revolutions-i-the-atlantic-and-france/complete-the-account-of-the-haitian-revolution

### 6. Arrange the stages of the fiscal-political crisis that opened the French Revolution.

**Answer:**

1. A century of wars leaves the crown unable to service its debt
2. Attempts to tax the privileged orders are blocked
3. The Estates General is summoned for the first time since 1614
4. The third estate declares itself the National Assembly
5. Popular insurrection in Paris makes the Assembly’s position irreversible

**Why:** Each step removes an option. Debt forces the crown to seek revenue; blocked reform forces it to seek consent; consent creates a body that redefines itself; and the insurrection makes dispersing that body impossible. By mid-July there is no route back to May, which is what makes this a revolution rather than a reform.

Page: https://tryals.app/practice/history-ii/the-age-of-revolutions-i-the-atlantic-and-france/arrange-the-stages-of-the-fiscal-political-crisis-that-opened-the

### 7. In which year did Haiti declare its independence?

**Answer:** 1804

**Why:** **1804**: the same year Napoleon promulgated the Civil Code and crowned himself emperor. The coincidence is a useful one to hold: the year the revolution’s legal settlement was codified in Europe is the year its most radical consequence declared itself in the Caribbean, and only one of the two got into the textbooks.

Page: https://tryals.app/practice/history-ii/the-age-of-revolutions-i-the-atlantic-and-france/in-which-year-did-haiti-declare-its-independence

### 8. Sort each position on the French Revolution by whether it belongs to the SOCIAL interpretation or to the REVISIONIST critique of it.

**Answer:**

- Social interpretation: A bourgeois revolution destroying a feudal order, Lefebvre and Soboul are the leading exponents
- Revisionist critique: The class categories fit the actual participants poorly, The Revolution is best read as a political and discursive event, Cobban and Furet mounted the main attacks

**Why:** The revisionist case rests partly on prosopography: the men of the assemblies were overwhelmingly lawyers and officeholders rather than merchants or manufacturers, which fits a bourgeois-capitalist revolution badly. The reply is that a class can be represented by people who are not typical of it, and that is where the argument still sits.

Page: https://tryals.app/practice/history-ii/the-age-of-revolutions-i-the-atlantic-and-france/sort-each-position-on-the-french-revolution-by-whether-it-belongs-to

### 9. The Declaration of the Rights of Man asserted universal rights in 1789, yet France only abolished colonial slavery in 1794 under the pressure of the Saint-Domingue uprising. What does this gap reveal about the initial revolutionary consensus?

A. Universal principles were bounded by imperial and economic priorities
B. The Third Estate rejected legal equality beyond metropolitan borders
C. Revolutionary leaders viewed colonial slavery as an essential social good
D. The Declaration applied solely to active citizens with taxable property

**Answer:** A. Universal principles were bounded by imperial and economic priorities

**Why:** Metropolitan legislators initially decoupled domestic civic equality from the colonial plantation economy. Emancipation was forced by the enslaved population's revolt rather than being an immediate translation of 1789 philosophy. Modern scholarship stresses how imperial commerce circumscribed abstract universalism.

Page: https://tryals.app/practice/history-ii/the-age-of-revolutions-i-the-atlantic-and-france/the-declaration-of-the-rights-of-man-asserted-universal-rights-in

### 10. Palmer and Godechot’s "Atlantic revolution" framework has been criticised for the marginal place it gives Haiti.

**Answer:** True

**Why:** **True.** A framework built around a shared democratic movement has difficulty accommodating a revolution whose central demand, the abolition of slavery, the other three either avoided or actively resisted. Trouillot pressed the point further: the silence is not an oversight but a structural feature of how the period was narrated.

Page: https://tryals.app/practice/history-ii/the-age-of-revolutions-i-the-atlantic-and-france/palmer-and-godechots-atlantic-revolution-framework-has-been

### 11. Trouillot argued that the Haitian revolution was "unthinkable" to contemporaries. What does that claim mean, given that Europeans plainly knew it was happening?

A. They saw it as inevitable racial savagery rather than an organised campaign for statehood
B. They secretly acknowledged its universal rights legitimacy, but censorship banned debate
C. They lacked categories to view slave revolt as political, treating it as banditry instead
D. They dismissed it as a British-funded plot designed to undermine French colonial commerce

**Answer:** C. They lacked categories to view slave revolt as political, treating it as banditry instead

**Why:** Unthinkable here means unavailable as a category, not unknown as a fact. Reports were plentiful and were fitted into frames — disorder, savagery, British intrigue — that preserved the assumption that the enslaved were not political agents. Trouillot’s argument is that the historiography then inherited those frames along with the sources.

Page: https://tryals.app/practice/history-ii/the-age-of-revolutions-i-the-atlantic-and-france/trouillot-argued-that-the-haitian-revolution-was-unthinkable-to