Practice question · Sort into groups
Sort each formulation: Eurocentric habit or Chakrabarty’s corrective?
Groups: Eurocentric habit · Corrective
- Africa lacked states
- Ask why that sequence is the benchmark at all
- India had no bourgeois revolution
- This society is not yet ready for self-rule
- Describe what was present rather than measure what was absent
- Notice the waiting room, and ask who built it
Hints
- One column is a sentence structure rather than a finding.
- Saying a society failed to develop something presumes a norm.
Show the answer
Eurocentric habit: India had no bourgeois revolution, This society is not yet ready for self-rule, Africa lacked states
Corrective: Ask why that sequence is the benchmark at all, Notice the waiting room, and ask who built it, Describe what was present rather than measure what was absent
Why
The left column is a sentence structure, not a finding. "Failed to develop X" only parses if the European sequence is the norm, which is the assumption doing all the work.
Practise Postcolonialism and Subaltern Studies
The app has 5 more questions on this lesson, and keeps your place in the course. History I is free to start.
More questions on Postcolonialism and Subaltern Studies
- Said held that Orientalist scholarship was superb AND that it served empire. Why are those two claims not in…
- Why was Guha unsatisfied by nationalist history, which had already displaced the British account?
- Why does Spivak answer "can the subaltern speak?" largely in the negative?
- Most surviving evidence of peasant revolt is police and court records. What does that do to a history of the…
- Said held that Orientalist scholarship could be both technically excellent and an instrument of empire.
- Chakrabarty says the "waiting room of history" still speaks someone else’s grammar. Whose, and why does that…
- Spivak argues that to be heard the subaltern must use forms belonging to the power being resisted. Why does…
- What four questions does this tradition hand a working historian, of anywhere?