Practice question · Put in order
Arrange these positions from the strongest claim about a connection between law and morality to the weakest.
- A system that fails every requirement of the internal morality of law is not a legal system
- A rule is not law once its injustice becomes intolerable
- Validity and merit are separate questions, and a valid rule may be as unjust as you like
- Any rule that is grossly unjust is for that reason not law
Hints
- The first two differ only in where the threshold sits.
- The last entry denies the connection entirely.
Show the answer
- Any rule that is grossly unjust is for that reason not law
- A rule is not law once its injustice becomes intolerable
- A system that fails every requirement of the internal morality of law is not a legal system
- Validity and merit are separate questions, and a valid rule may be as unjust as you like
Why
The gradient matters because the debate is usually taught as two camps. In fact the interesting disagreements are about thresholds: Radbruch and the strong natural lawyer differ over how much injustice is needed, and Fuller's claim is weaker still, being about the form of rules rather than their content.
Practise Law, Morality, Custom and Force
The app has 5 more questions on this lesson, and keeps your place in the course. Law I is free to start.
More questions on Law, Morality, Custom and Force
- Hart held that a sufficiently unjust rule is, for that reason, not a legal rule at all.
- Arrange these contributions to the debate about law and morality in chronological order.
- Which are true of the separability thesis?
- Complete the account of the border between law and its neighbours.
- How many requirements does Fuller's internal morality of law contain?
- Legal positivism insists upon separating what the law is from what it ought to be. What practical consequence…
- The Wolfenden Report recommended in 1957 that private consensual homosexual conduct between adults cease to…
- Austin's command theory cannot account for rules that confer powers, such as those governing how to make a…