Practice question · Multiple choice
Cyclical theories of history become popular during periods of perceived decline. What methodological warning does that pattern carry?
Hints
- Ask who decides when Rome 'ended', and what happens to the pattern if you choose differently.
- The phases fit. Were they fitted?
Show the answer
B. That the cycle may be imposed rather than found
Why
Boundaries are analyst's decisions and the shape follows from them, so a well-fitting cycle may be a curve drawn through points chosen to suit it. Popularity in bad times is a hint about motive rather than proof of error, a theory can be both consoling and correct, which is why the test has to be the boundary-drawing.
Practise Cyclical Theories of History
The app has 5 more questions on this lesson, and keeps your place in the course. History I is free to start.
More questions on Cyclical Theories of History
- What makes Ibn Khaldun’s cycle a genuine model rather than a metaphor?
- Ibn Khaldun’s asabiyyah rises in the desert and decays in the city over about four generations. Why does that…
- Put Ibn Khaldun’s dynastic cycle in order.
- Sort each feature: does it make a theory testable or unfalsifiable?
- For Toynbee, a civilization grows best when its challenge is as severe as possible.
- Match each theorist to their signature and their flaw.