Practice question · True or false
The Peace of God movement from 989 is read by some historians as evidence of a sudden crisis of violence and by others as evidence of continuity.
Hints
- Ask whether an attempt to limit private war proves that private war has just increased.
- The same document supports both readings depending on what you assume preceded it.
Show the answer
True
Why
True, and it is a good illustration of how the same source serves two cases. To Duby and Bonnassie the Peace councils show churchmen reacting to a new castellan violence; to Barthélemy they show a church doing what it had long done, newly visible because the documents change. The evidence underdetermines the verdict.
Practise Feudal Society
The app has 4 more questions on this lesson, and keeps your place in the course. History II is free to start.
More questions on Feudal Society
- Susan Reynolds argued in Fiefs and Vassals that the "feudal system" is largely a construction of later…
- Sort each item by whether it describes the LORD–VASSAL relation or the LORD–PEASANT relation.
- Which claims about the "three orders" model are defensible?
- Marc Bloch’s definition of feudal society is narrower than F. L. Ganshof’s, being restricted to the legal tie…
- Complete the account of the seigneurie as an economic unit.
- The seigneurie extracted wealth through judicial fines and banalités alongside agricultural rents. What does…
- Arrange the stages of the argument for a "feudal revolution" around the year 1000, as its proponents present…
- A tenant owes three days of week-work in a six-day week, plus rent in kind, plus compulsory paid use of the…
- A tenant owes three days of week-work in a seven-day week. Estimate the percentage of the year’s days he owes…
- Arrange these contributions to the debate about feudalism in the order they were made.