Practice question · Put in order
Arrange these positions on language origins from the most gradualist to the most saltationist.
- Language grew continuously out of primate call systems
- A single change enabling recursion produced language essentially at once
- Language began in gesture and shifted channel over time
- Language assembled from several separately evolved capacities
Hints
- Gradualist accounts posit many small steps.
- The single-change account is the most abrupt.
Show the answer
- Language grew continuously out of primate call systems
- Language began in gesture and shifted channel over time
- Language assembled from several separately evolved capacities
- A single change enabling recursion produced language essentially at once
Why
Ranking them makes the axis explicit: the disagreement is about how many steps, and therefore about how much of language is a modification of things other animals have. The saltationist end is what makes the Pirahã recursion dispute so heated, a single counter-example matters far more to a one-step account.
Practise Origins, Evolution and Linguistic Relativity
The app has 3 more questions on this lesson, and keeps your place in the course. Languages I is free to start.
More questions on Origins, Evolution and Linguistic Relativity
- The Russian-blues advantage disappears when speakers perform a verbal task at the same time. Why does that…
- Sort each claim by whether it belongs to linguistic DETERMINISM or the weaker RELATIVITY.
- FOXP2 is best described as the gene for language.
- The human descended larynx increases choking hazards yet expands phonetic range. Why does this morphological…
- What is the maximum number of basic colour terms Berlin and Kay found in any language?
- Which are legitimate reasons to be cautious about evidence for the origin of language?
- Match each domain to the relativity finding associated with it.
- The claim that a language has dozens of words for snow, even if true, would not by itself show anything about…
- Complete the account of the two hypotheses.