Languages I / Origins, Evolution and Linguistic Relativity
Practice question · Put in order

Arrange these positions on language origins from the most gradualist to the most saltationist.

Hints
  1. Gradualist accounts posit many small steps.
  2. The single-change account is the most abrupt.
Show the answer
  1. Language grew continuously out of primate call systems
  2. Language began in gesture and shifted channel over time
  3. Language assembled from several separately evolved capacities
  4. A single change enabling recursion produced language essentially at once
Why

Ranking them makes the axis explicit: the disagreement is about how many steps, and therefore about how much of language is a modification of things other animals have. The saltationist end is what makes the Pirahã recursion dispute so heated, a single counter-example matters far more to a one-step account.

Read the lesson: Origins, Evolution and Linguistic Relativity →

Practise Origins, Evolution and Linguistic Relativity

The app has 3 more questions on this lesson, and keeps your place in the course. Languages I is free to start.

More questions on Origins, Evolution and Linguistic Relativity