Practice question · Multiple choice
The boundary problem asserts that defining the citizenry cannot be settled by democratic voting. Why is this logically so, and what does it imply for democratic legitimacy?
Hints
- Who would be entitled to participate in an election that decides who is allowed to participate?
- Can a democratic procedure validate its own initial starting conditions without circular logic?
Show the answer
C. A vote on who may vote already presupposes an established demos
Why
Treating franchise limits as resolvable by majority rule creates infinite regress, as deciding the original electorate requires a pre-existing decision. Equating democracy with sheer universalism ignores constitutional design, whilst representative filtering addresses policy rather than membership.
Practise Democracy and Polyarchy
The app has 5 more questions on this lesson, and keeps your place in the course. Political Science I is free to start.
More questions on Democracy and Polyarchy
- Which are true of Dahl's concept of polyarchy?
- Schumpeter defined democracy as a method for choosing a government rather than as a state of affairs.
- Complete the account of democratic theory.
- Sort each requirement by whether it concerns ELECTION DAY or the period BETWEEN elections.
- How many institutional requirements for polyarchy does Dahl list?
- Arrange these regime types from the most closed to the most open on Dahl's two dimensions.
- Athens at its height had a citizen body entitled to vote in the assembly. Roughly what percentage of the…