Political Science I / Democracy and Polyarchy
Practice question · Multiple choice

The boundary problem asserts that defining the citizenry cannot be settled by democratic voting. Why is this logically so, and what does it imply for democratic legitimacy?

Hints
  1. Who would be entitled to participate in an election that decides who is allowed to participate?
  2. Can a democratic procedure validate its own initial starting conditions without circular logic?
Show the answer

C. A vote on who may vote already presupposes an established demos

Why

Treating franchise limits as resolvable by majority rule creates infinite regress, as deciding the original electorate requires a pre-existing decision. Equating democracy with sheer universalism ignores constitutional design, whilst representative filtering addresses policy rather than membership.

Read the lesson: Democracy and Polyarchy →

Practise Democracy and Polyarchy

The app has 5 more questions on this lesson, and keeps your place in the course. Political Science I is free to start.

More questions on Democracy and Polyarchy