Practice question · Put in order
Arrange the steps of the 1859 preface’s account of how a mode of production is transformed.
- An era of social revolution opens
- New relations of production establish themselves and development resumes
- Those relations, once suited to the forces, begin to obstruct them
- The productive forces develop within existing relations of production
- The obstruction is experienced as a conflict between classes
Hints
- The sequence begins with growth inside the existing arrangement, not with a grievance.
- Marx’s word for relations that used to help and now hinder is "fetters".
Show the answer
- The productive forces develop within existing relations of production
- Those relations, once suited to the forces, begin to obstruct them
- The obstruction is experienced as a conflict between classes
- An era of social revolution opens
- New relations of production establish themselves and development resumes
Why
Notice what the sequence does not contain: any moment at which people simply decide the arrangement is unjust. Marx locates the trigger in a mismatch between what a society can produce and how it is organised to produce it, which is what makes the account materialist rather than moral.
Practise Comte and Marx
The app has 4 more questions on this lesson, and keeps your place in the course. Sociology I is free to start.
More questions on Comte and Marx
- Comte placed sociology last in his hierarchy of the sciences, after mathematics, astronomy, physics,…
- Complete the account of Comte’s system.
- Comte’s law of three stages holds that knowledge passes from the theological to the positive and only then to…
- Estimate how many years separate the first volume of Comte’s Cours de philosophie positive from the first…
- In which year did Marx and Engels publish the Communist Manifesto?
- Sort each element by whether Marx places it in the economic base or in the superstructure that rises on it.
- Marx’s writings on alienation were composed in 1844 but not published until 1932, so they played no part in…
- Arrange these moments in the lives and works of Comte and Marx, earliest first.
- Some readers take historical materialism to mean that legal, religious and political forms are simply effects…
- For Comte, social conflict is a curable pathology, whereas for Marx, it is the fundamental driver of…