Sort each item by whether it is characteristic of the SOURCES available for medieval history or for contemporary history.
Groups: Medieval sources · Contemporary sources
- A handful of charters surviving from one monastery
- Mass-circulation newspapers held in national libraries
- Systematic census and government statistical series
- Archaeological evidence for diet and building materials
- Photographic, film and later sound recording
Hints
- One column is defined by scarcity and the other by abundance.
- Ask which set of problems a historian faces when there are millions of documents rather than three.
Show the answer
Medieval sources: A handful of charters surviving from one monastery, Archaeological evidence for diet and building materials
Contemporary sources: Mass-circulation newspapers held in national libraries, Systematic census and government statistical series, Photographic, film and later sound recording
The methodological consequence is the interesting part. Scarcity forces the medievalist to squeeze every source and to argue explicitly about representativeness. Abundance lets the contemporary historian find evidence for almost any thesis, which makes the principle of selection, rarely stated, the place where the interpretation actually happens.
Practise What "Contemporary History" Is
The app has 3 more questions on this lesson, and keeps your place in the course. History II is free to start.
More questions on What "Contemporary History" Is
- The Romance-language tradition begins contemporary history around 1789, while anglophone usage often reserves…
- Arrange these developments in the writing of history, earliest first.
- Koselleck argued that before roughly 1750 the word "revolution" carried the sense of a turning or a return…
- Koselleck defines the Sattelzeit by a divergence between the 'space of experience' and the 'horizon of…
- Complete Koselleck’s account of what changed between roughly 1750 and 1850.
- Why do historians say that a period boundary is an argument rather than a fact?
- Match each periodisation to the claim it makes.
- In which year did the Universitat de Barcelona syllabus’s period end, the closing date this course takes for…
- Arrange the steps of the argument that period labels shape historical explanation.
- The Annales school, founded in 1929, is chiefly associated with a return to diplomatic and political…