Practice question · Put in order
Rank these four Milgram variations from the HIGHEST level of obedience down to the LOWEST, reasoning from how close the authority and the victim are in each.
- Experimenter present in the room; learner in the same room, visible and audible.
- Experimenter present in the room; participant must force the learner's hand onto the shock plate.
- Experimenter absent from the building, issuing all instructions by telephone.
- Experimenter present in the room; learner unseen and unheard in another room.
Hints
- Work down the victim-proximity ladder first: unseen, then seen, then touched.
- Removing the authority from the room entirely is the biggest single drop of the four - larger even than the touch condition.
Show the answer
- Experimenter present in the room; learner unseen and unheard in another room.
- Experimenter present in the room; learner in the same room, visible and audible.
- Experimenter present in the room; participant must force the learner's hand onto the shock plate.
- Experimenter absent from the building, issuing all instructions by telephone.
Why
Obedience is highest when the victim is remote and the authority is present, and falls step by step as the victim becomes vivid (seen, then touched). The steepest fall comes when the authority leaves and phones his orders in, because what holds the participant in place is the authority's physical presence - remove that and most of the obedience goes with it.
Practise Conformity and Obedience: The Power of Social Influence
The app has 6 more questions on this lesson, and keeps your place in the course. Psychology I is free to start.
More questions on Conformity and Obedience: The Power of Social Influence
- Each person below yields to social pressure. Decide which kind of influence is actually operating in each…
- Select every statement that these studies ACTUALLY demonstrated, as opposed to what is popularly claimed…
- Milgram's shock generator rose in 15-volt steps. A design with one switch marked "450 volts, dangerous" would…
- Milgram's obedience rate fell from 65% to about 21% when the experimenter gave instructions by telephone…