Sort each feature of a situation by whether dissonance theory predicts it will produce more or less attitude change in the person who acted against their own view.
Groups: Predicts MORE attitude change · Predicts LESS attitude change
- The act was public and cannot now be denied
- The person was given a ready excuse: everyone in the room had been instructed to say it
- The person was openly threatened with a heavy penalty for refusing
- The reward for the counter-attitudinal act was trivially small
Hints
- The single question to ask of each feature is: does it hand the person an excuse they can point to?
- Threats and instructions are excuses; free choice, public commitment and unrewarded suffering are not.
Show the answer
Predicts MORE attitude change: The reward for the counter-attitudinal act was trivially small, The act was public and cannot now be denied
Predicts LESS attitude change: The person was given a ready excuse: everyone in the room had been instructed to say it, The person was openly threatened with a heavy penalty for refusing
Anything that supplies external justification - payment, orders, threats - absorbs the dissonance and leaves the attitude alone. Anything that strips justification away - free choice, irreversibility, unrewarded effort - forces the belief to move instead. Note that a heavy threat behaves exactly like a large payment here, which surprises most students.
Practise Cognitive Dissonance and the Drive for Consistency
The app has 6 more questions on this lesson, and keeps your place in the course. Psychology I is free to start.
More questions on Cognitive Dissonance and the Drive for Consistency
- Select every outcome that cognitive dissonance theory actually predicts.
- Groups with harsh initiations — fraternities, elite units, some professions — tend to command stronger…
- Participants paid one dollar to lie about a boring task later rated it as genuinely more enjoyable than those…
- Trace the causal chain by which a 1-dollar participant ends up genuinely believing the task was interesting.…